Miss Teenager America

1958
Brenda Brednax
Dallas, Texas

1959

1960

1961
Diane Leynne Cox
Richmond, Virginia

1962
Darla Banks
Fresno, California

1963 (Renunció)
Jydy Doll
Arkon, Ohio

1963 Suplente
Jeanine Zavrel
Washington, Distrit of Columbia

1964
Carolyn Mignini
Baltimore, Maryland

1965
Colete Agnes Daiute
New York City, New York

1966
Sandy Roberts
Milpetos, California

1967
Stephanie Ann Crane
St. Louis, Missouri

1968
Melissa Babish
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

1969
Debbie Patton
Odessa, Texas

1970
Rowa C. Walsh
Anaheim, California

1971
Mary Colleen Fritzpatrick
Lancaster, Ohio

1972
Melissa Marie Galbraith
Clarion, Pennsylvania